Welcome to Sign in | Join | Help
in
CBS47 Home Community Home Anchor Blogs Photo Galleries Valley Events

Tech Tracker

My take on the Palm Pre vs The Apple IPhone - Part 1

I picked up the Palm Pre when it came out June 6th....returned it the 24th, and picked up the IPhone3GS.

I've seen tons of articles and reviews comparing the two, but I haven't really heard which one was better for the average user. Not which one has the best features, fastest load times, biggest hard drive. I wanted to know for the average grab and go user, which one was going to work best.

I followed the Palm Pre since it was announced at CES earlier this year and was really excited. It seemed to have everything the IPhone was lacking; picture messaging, interchangeable batteries(without bulky backpacks or weird tethered add-ons), and a physical keyboard.

I've had an account with Sprint for almost 8 years now and that was my biggest reason for not jumping in with everyone else picking up the IPhone....plus there were cheaper options that were still pretty good.

I held on to my Treo650 for as long as I could

made a disastrous switch to the HTC Mogul

and was overjoyed when Sprint finally offered up a worthy mobile device -The Palm Pre.

Let me start off by saying that I loved the Palm Pre....if you lived next to a cell tower and only needed it for 6 hours/day....it's is the perfect phone.

The battery barely lasted a day with moderate use and the reception went from awesome to nothing to awesome...without even moving. Places where I had no trouble getting reception with previous phones were now a struggle. I would get maybe 1 bar in my house in the Tower District, 5 bars in Riverpark.....and what made me laugh.....I was ROAMING in the Apple Store while waiting to pick up my IPhone.

The keyboard on the Pre did seem a little cramped at first, but it only took about a day to get used to it.

One of the "neatest" features was Synergy. It would pull info from your AOL Instant Messenger, Facebook, and Google accounts and combine it with your contacts and calendar on the phone. You were even able to link all of the info from the different sources to one calendar or even 1 contact in your address book.

For example; I added created a new contact for my mom with her home phone number and called it Mom. Then after signing in to all of my accounts I now had 3 different contacts in my address book for my mom. 1 for AIM, 1 for Facebook, and the one I added. Synergy allowed me to link all of the profiles together, so when I clicked on Mom it pulled up her picture and email address from Facebook, her AIM screen name, and her phone number that I added.

It was even easier for people who had added more contact info on their Facebook profile. For some friends I didn't have to add any info, it was already there...and as they updated their profiles, it updated my phone as well.

I loved taking pictures with the Pre. From the same menu I could email a photo, send it to another phone, or even upload it to Facebook or Photobucket.

Now I now most of what I have said is only an App away with the IPhone......

...but imagine being able to do it all at the same time, without having to quit one to start another.

Multitasking it the #1 feature I really don't think I can live without. It's a world of difference when you can listen to music on Pandora, check out the latest blog entry's online, have a conversation via AIM and text, be able to reference an email, and check out my calendar....without having to close anything. Try doing that with an IPhone.

Palm is lagging a little with getting their SDK out...and their App Catalogue is hurting. It's been out for a month and barely has 30 apps available compared to the thousands now available for the IPhone.

All of those great things aside.....If I can't make or receive a phone call....it's hard to justify spending $200.

I'm out of time tonight, but part 2 with the IPhone3GS will come soon.

Published Friday, July 10, 2009 9:52 PM by Matt Hackney

Comments

 

godogs said:

Good information Tech Tracker.
Thanks for sharing.
I hear there's an app on the iphone - that let's you watch TV.  
Is that true?
Can I watch CBS 47 on an iphone  ?
July 12, 2009 1:04 PM
 

PHil100a said:

Oh, PLEASE! One day of use with a new phone in an undisclosed network location and you give up?!? I and 14 people in my company just got Pre's. Three are on the East Coast - three in the midwest - and eight on the west coast. ALL of our phones work fine - and everyone loves them. btw, five of those people were iPhine users, including two Apple fanboys. The latter two have been converted.

Palm isn't trying to kill the iPhone; it's a WEB phone, for busy people. It multitasks, and is running on a great network (Sprint). I've had Verizoan and ATT and they are both inferior to the reach of the Sprint network - NO contest. Also, Sprint's all-you-can-eat subscription is $99, compared to $150 for ATT (not including sneaky add-ons). Guess what? Sprint sold me an Air Card, and a sub for 5GIG data on the card for $50 per month, with the card for FREE! That means for $150, I get all I can eat data, the Air Card anytime, anywhere network at 5GIG (a TON of bandwidth) for LESS than ATT can give me just all I can eat. If I didn't have the air card, I'd save $1400.00 over two years with Sprint!! Can you beat that? I multitask a LOT, and I do other things that the Pre does and the iPhone doesn't. I'm too busy to play with apps - games, mind twisters, pretend beer chugging, and all that nonsense. I want my phone to WORK for me. My phone isi not an entertainment machine (although sound on the Pre easily matches what you get from an iPhone. Just wait till the newly released Paln SDK starts getting used. Last, I think yuor review is pretty lame, given that when I had my ATT phone (three years), their network SUCKED in San Francisco and the Peninsula - going in and out all the time. I have NEVER had that problem with Sprint. IN four years with Sprint I have not had more than 4-5 dopped calls. So, if you want to continue dropping $1400 per year more for yuor data, be my guest. Next time, do a real test - check out 2-3 phones (you may have gotten a lemon). Oh, yeah, when it comes time to change your battery, enjoy paying $50 just to have it installed PLUS the cost of the battery. Last, Apple is LAME for trying to keep Palm users from synching with iTunes. Who needs Apple's lame pricing anyway. I get my tunes from Amazon. btw, I grok all of Apples other products. They're great, so is the iPhone, but please do a decent review next time. You come off like a shill for Apple, and completely misrepresent the Pre and Sprint by saying you "can't  make a call". Ridiculous! and LAME!
July 19, 2009 1:56 AM
 

Matt Hackney said:

I guess I should clarify a few things with my review, I had it for 20 days of very active use, spent many hours on the phone with sprint as well as taking it in and having them check the Pre out...only to have them give it back saying nothing was wrong with it.

I had been with Sprint for 5 years and had no problems with them or their service until I started using the Pre. In places were I had no trouble with other sprint phones in the past, the Pre struggled.

I'm not the only one with issues, I think this website will show you that it is pretty well documented.

http://forums.precentral.net/palm-pre/182595-buglist-pre.html

I love that the Pre multitasks, and I'm hurting without it on the IPhone.

The point of my post wasn't to address the the plans or networks, but just the devices. There is a little bit of a price jump for me though when I switched to AT&T.

I also want my phone to work for me, and the Palm Pre's short falls made me feel like it might not be there when I needed it.

As far as the ITunes syncing, well it's looks like the newest update for the Pre has fixed it.

http://www.engadget.com/2009/07/23/palm-webos-1-1-now-available-fixes-itunes-sync/

I am by no means and Apple fanboy, I'm probably closer to being a one for Palm way before Apple. I'm still trying out the IPhone and when I feel I've gotten to know it better I will finish my comparison of the two. It will be up to you to decide which works better for you.
July 23, 2009 11:43 PM
Anonymous comments are disabled

This Blog

Post Calendar

<July 2009>
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
2829301234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930311
2345678

Syndication

Inergize Digital Media This site powered by Inergize Digital Media. The views expressed here do not necessarily reflect the views of this station.